Book Review of THE BRILLIANT – His Bloody Project, Graeme Macrae Burnet

A small town murder occurs, in true ‘TV detective Columbo’ style you know who did it, but you are still drawn into the tale. Brutal moments, hidden undercurrents and stubborn survival instincts all described simply and in deserved prize-winning ways.

HIs Bloody Project Book Cover

HIs Bloody Project Book Cover

Book Review – His Bloody Project, Graeme Macrae Burnet

Book Review

Title: His Bloody Project

Author: Graeme Macrae Burnet

Copyright: Graeme Macrae Burnet 2015

Ebook

Blurb: The year is 1869. A brutal triple murder in a remote community in the Scottish Highlands leads to the arrest of a young man by the name of Roderick Macrae. A memoir written by the accused makes it clear that he is guilty, but it falls to the country’s finest legal and psychiatric minds to uncover what drove him to commit such merciless acts of violence. Was he mad? Only the persuasive powers of his advocate stand between Macrae and the gallows.

Plot (or subject if non fiction): This aspect is confusing. Is it fiction, or non-fiction. It’s brilliant and I’m guessing it’s fiction compiled around fact. That’s what it says it is.

Isn’t all fact just one person’s version of events? History is after all, HIS STORY, yes some feminists did want to change the word.

A small town murder occurs, in true ‘TV detective Columbo’ style you know who did it, but you are still drawn into the tale. Brutal moments, hidden undercurrents and stubborn survival instincts all described simply and in deserved prize-winning ways.

You must read the whole book, don’t do what I confess I often do, which is to skip the preface.

I’m looking into my own heritage. If I can uncover a long lost relative like Roddy and put together a compulsive and heart wrending story around the facts as Graeme has I’ll be thrilled.

OR is it totally fiction, all made up in Mr Macrae’s imagination? I’m still not sure!

Characters: Roderick Macrae – a descendant of the author, a grieving son of a, now deceased, loving mother Una

Roderick’s father John Macrae – recently widowed, hard man of the hills, struggling to keep afloat

Lachlan Mackenzie aka Lachlan Broad – not a nice chap, but did he deserve what he got?

Conclusion:  The ‘story’ is funny, heart breaking and educational. It will make you glad you’re alive now and not in the time or place of the events at the heart of the book. 

I love an underdog so it really broke my heart.

The court scene has discussions that brought to mind the old skulls you can find in museums when they studied phrenology as a science. The so called experts of a view that there was a ‘criminal class’ you could spot by their physical attributes.

I guess in some ways we haven’t come that far, you still hear people saying ‘he looked dodgy.’ Maybe we are hard wired to judge by appearance.

Recommended: YES YES and YES. I don’t usually like or always understand the Booker prize choices but this is one I whole heartedly agree with. It has become one of my FAVOURITE books.

Pick it up, devour it and let me know if you agree, I’m sure you will.

You may also like:

http://www.christieadamswriter.com/forensics-the-anatomy-of-crime-val-mcdermid/

Book Review – The Missing, C L Taylor

https://www.waterstones.com/author/graeme-macrae-burnet/1886613

Handy Shopping Links (If you use my links to go to pages such as Amazon, to book your holidays, or investigate software options I earn a small commission. You’re supporting my work, enabling me to continue writing and keep this website and content free to you, thank you!)

I hope I’ve inspired you to buy a book and read more. Tweet me from your next coffee stop! If you are busy out and about and you’d like my posts to your email inbox directly, please sign up for the newsletter.


Author: christieadamswriter.com

I’m a storyteller focused on sharing my love of literature, travel, photography and all things arty.
My blogging supports my writing and I’m committed to encouraging others to pursue their dreams through travel and the arts.